Saints Island Pies

6236 Main St, Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 2S4, Canada
$$$ Pizza restaurant
(108 Reviews)
Price Range $20–30

Welcome to Saints Island Pies, an inviting haven for pizza lovers located at 6236 Main St, Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON. This delightful pizza restaurant brings an innovative twist to traditional pizza with flavors inspired by Filipino cuisine and a charming island flair. Whether you’re in for a casual meal or a cozy gathering with friends or family, Saints Island Pies promises a dining experience that’s both delicious and delightful.

The menu is a vibrant reflection of their unique culinary identity, featuring a variety of mouthwatering options that cater to every palate. For those looking to start their meal with some appetizers, dive into the Lumpia Shanghai, four pieces of crispy pork-filled spring rolls served with refreshing Bibb lettuce and sweet chili sauce, priced at CA$11.00. You might also want to try their comforting Mushroom Arroz Caldo, a warm rice porridge enriched with shiitake mushrooms, crispy garlic, and topped with a soft egg for just CA$13.00.

The true stars of the menu, of course, are the large pies. Take a trip on the flavorful side with their Maanghang Puti (Spicy White Pie), a fiery blend that will excite your taste buds for CA$32.00. For a delightful amalgamation of tastes, the Plantation Pie marries smokey achuete marinated pork with sweet pineapple and a flavorful signature sauce all for CA$24.00. Don't forget to finish off your meal with their enticing Shakoy, a sweet fried dough tossed in sugar, perfect for sharing at CA$6.00.

Visitors rave about the beautiful ambiance of Saints, which is a splendid blend of modern design and cozy charm that makes for the ideal backdrop for any occasion. The space is bright and airy, offering a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Many patrons have praised the staff for their friendliness and attentiveness – it’s clear that the team here prioritizes creating a warm and positive dining experience. Customer reviews highlight moments of delightful service and delectable eats, with diners frequently expressing a desire to return and share their experiences with others.

Fans of unique pizza flavors will find themselves at home here, as the restaurant has become a beloved neighborhood gem. The authentic flavors reflect the rich culinary heritage of the Philippines, setting Saints Island Pies apart from typical pizza places. Experience the island-inspired twist on pizza and savor an unforgettable meal that will have you coming back for more!

Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Service options
Has outdoor seating
Offers kerbside pickup
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves cocktails
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has seating
Atmosphere
Casual
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
108 Reviews
Abiram Suvendran

19 Sep 2025

Went on a Sunday night and ordered a longganisa pizza and calamansi wings with a black pepper ranch style sauce. For the price the pizza was underwhelming. Pizza was slightly smaller than expected and undercooked tbh. Pretty doughy. Also had less toppings than expected. However, the ingredients like the sausage, cherry coke bbq sauce were good. Pizza - 2/5 The wings were better. The citrus and spice was a great combo. Also the black pepper dip was really good. However the dip was a little too strong for the wings. Overwhelmed the subtle sweetness, spice and citrus notes. Wings - 3.5/5 It was only their 4th day open at this location, so I’m sure it will be better. Like the other reviews I’ve read, maybe try the new york style.

Sebastian Baechler

09 Sep 2025

The pizzas were delicious and the portions were perfect. The staff and owner are super welcoming and nice too. Will definitely be coming back

Robin W

04 Sep 2025

The old Bakehouse location has reopened as Saints on Main! We visited frequently when their pizzeria only ran in the evenings and we looked forward to them reopening and rebranding as the new owners of the space. We visited last night and food was beautiful and flavourful as we’ve come to expect from Saints! Interior work is a great refresh - light, airy while still familiar and cozy - and R&B music beats kept a nice laid back vibe. Staff was delightful and attentive. Looking forward to coming back after they add desserts too.

CARLO ELZINGRE

30 Aug 2025

What a hidden gem! The pizza flavor is so original and really, really good—something you don’t find everywhere. Big shout-out to Chef Jan for the amazing food, and to our wonderful server for making the experience even better. I’m definitely coming back and telling all my friends about this spot!

Stan

01 Aug 2025

Beautiful restaurant! I stopped by last Sunday night and was pleasantly surprised by the food and service. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Natasha (I think that was her name) served me and my father. She was so friendly and welcoming. Growing up in the restaurant industry, you realize that, yes, the food is important, but service is what makes or breaks a meal.

C P

20 Jul 2025

A really nice little restaurant in the evenings and bakery during the day. The pizzas are amazing they use different ingredients which totally reflects their Philippines heritage. Each pizza is incredible we have tried them all. There are also wings and skewers which also have amazing flavors. Alcohol is available as well. The staff is super friendly and very cheerful! A neighborhood gem.

Genuine Lam

20 Jul 2025

Saints on Main is a wonderful new addition to Markham-Stouffville! Since my kids go to school in the area, I’ve been watching their impressive re-branding and renos from afar for a while now. Today I finally got to taste and see it in person - and Lord it’s good. The updated space is now bright, airy and cozy with an island/Filipino flair, perfect for an intimate coffee catch up with a friend or date alike. Apart from the interior space, the outdoor patio is fantastic also in these late summer days, with beautiful trees providing a comfortable shade. How can I forget the unforgettable food? I had the Longganisa Sandwich with the Maggi Garlic aioli - I only wish I had two of them! Every bite, from the flavor to texture to the aroma, was scrumptious. A must try whether you’re a fan of Filipino foods or not. The latte was pulled with a Nuova Simonelli with Detour beans. I had it with oat milk, and it was smooth and delicate, and quite a looker too! Service was excellent- servers were patient and knowledgeable as I was indecisive about what to order. Overall, this was a great experience that will definitely bring me back for more time and again. Looking forward to their creative and evolving menu options as the restaurant continues to grow.

Promise Shepherd

01 Jun 2025

Had the lechon which was amaZing! And the kids had cheese in NY style. Tbh I'll probably just get the lechon again next time but I'm totally open to trying all flavors. Detroit style is on point! You gotta dine-in the vibe is just right, alllll the staff is super too feels like family wish they weren't so far from us it's like a home away from home lol

Checking
Listing Image

Imperial Pizza

3528, 615 South Ave, Secane, PA 19018, United States
Pizza restaurant
(657 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Sushimono

9624 Bruceville Rd, Elk Grove, CA 95757, United States
Sushi restaurant
(425 Reviews)
Featured
Listing Image

Albitas

1280 Terminal Wy #17, Reno, NV 89502, United States
mexican restaurant
(325 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Laurelhurst Market

3155 E Burnside St, Portland, OR 97214, United States
Steak house
(873 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas

1002 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530, United States
Wine bar
(1147 Reviews)

Join the Saints Island Pies Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.